Snack Review

Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes York Peppermint Flavored

Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes York Peppermint Flavored

Buy snack cakes on Amazon

Taste test: These snack cakes had a rectangular shape with a nice smooth dark chocolate exterior decorated by some white peppermint squiggles on top.

Inside, top and bottom layers of chocolate cake surrounded a central peppermint creme layer. Much like Tastykake's Reese's Kandy Bar Kakes, which also licensed a Hershey's brand, these walked the fine line between claiming to be real York and just using their logo to make it look that way. One corner of the box box said generically "5 individually wrapped peppermint creme filled cakes" while the opposite corner said "York peppermint flavored." This was a closer match to the real thing than the Reese's version. The peppermint and chocolate flavor was kind of spot-on York, but just less dense (as we'd expect a snack cake to be vs. a peppermint pattie) and toned down in intensity a bunch. Pretty good for a snack cake with some chocolatey mint, but if you want to "Get the Sensation!" with more intensity and less bulk, you should get a real York.

Shop: Buy snack cakes on Amazon

Smell test: A lot like York Peppermint Patties, with a peppermint sharpness, but not as strong.

From the package: “The York trademark and trade dress are used under license”

Online store: Buy snack cakes on Amazon

Company: Tasty Baking Company

Reviews of similar snacks:

This snack was discovered by Jeremy at Market Basket. Review published .

Most popular reviews

Moon Lodge The Whole Shabang Potato Chips

Most popular in previous months

Latest reviews

Kras Dorina Kolumbo

Still hungry? Check out the 100 latest reviews

We tweet every review!

What We're Eating

More ...