photo of Pop-Tarts Frosted Watermelon
Pop-Tarts Frosted Watermelon

Snack Review

Pop-Tarts Frosted Watermelon

Buy snacks on Amazon

Taste test: This was one of the crazier Pop-Tarts flavors we've heard of, so it definitely seemed worth a try. Most of the top surface of each piece was covered with a pink frosting, a good match for watermelon's inside color, with some squiggles of green frosting that were a good match for the outside. The filling was redder than the frosting, but still well within the watermelon range of color.

For my taste test, I toasted one Pop-Tart and kept another one cold and then alternated between the two along with sips of cold milk. The untoasted one had a taste that was somewhat watermelon-like, though sweeter and obviously less watery. The toasted one had a much stronger watermelon flavor. Even the aftertaste reminded me of watermelon. I shared around untoasted pieces of the remaining Pop-Tarts with some friends, and most people thought they were pretty good. Two people independently declared that they tasted like Jolly Ranchers.

Shop: Buy snacks on Amazon

Smell test: It first, it smelled mostly like the Pop-Tarts dough, but on third whiff, I could detect an actual watermelon smell.

From the package: “Produced with Genetic Engineering” ... “Contains wheat and soy ingredients.” ... “Artificially flavored”

Online store: Buy snacks on Amazon

Company: Kellogg's

Reviews of similar snacks:

This snack was discovered by Jeremy at Market Basket. Review published .

Most popular reviews

Moon Lodge The Whole Shabang Potato Chips

Most popular in previous months

Latest reviews

YBC Chip Star Butter Soy Sauce

Still hungry? Check out the 100 latest reviews

We tweet every review!

What We're Eating

More ...