8404 snacks from 1611 companies in 76 countries!

photo of Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins

Snack Review

Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins

Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins

Buy Reese’s on Amazon

Taste test: With so many seasonal shapes of Reese's, I didn't know if it was worth trying one more, but this King Size pack was priced at just $1, so I figured, what the heck? The package promised two pumpkin-shaped pieces, which seemed odd, given how wide the pack was; with these proportions, seemed like it would have three or even four pumpkins.

I opened the wrapper to find that there were indeed just two pieces inside, but to call them pumpkin-shaped would be an extreme reach. They were just shaped like wide blobs, with almost no resemblance to pumpkins at all. It looked like they maybe tried to put a pumpkin stem in the bottom center, but it barely jutted out at all — and why the bottom?

As disappointing as the shape was, the good news was that these were still Reese's. The outside felt a bit melty on the fingertips, but each piece was fairly big, with a soft feel, lots of peanut butter and lots of chocolate.

Shop: Buy Reese’s on Amazon

Smell test: The usual Reese's smell. Nice.

From the package: “Orange background color is a registered trademark.”

Online store: Buy Reese’s on Amazon

Company: Hershey

Reviews of similar snacks:

All 195 snack categories

All 1611 snack companies

We tweet every review!

This snack was discovered by Jeremy at Target. Review published .

Latest snack reviews

Still hungry? Check out the 100 latest reviews

What We're Eating

More ...