photo of Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins
Snack Review

Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins

Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins

Buy Reese’s on Amazon #ad

Taste test: With so many seasonal shapes of Reese's, I didn't know if it was worth trying one more, but this King Size pack was priced at just $1, so I figured, what the heck? The package promised two pumpkin-shaped pieces, which seemed odd, given how wide the pack was; with these proportions, seemed like it would have three or even four pumpkins.

Similar snacks

Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups SkullsButterfinger Peanut Butter Cups EggReester BunniesButterfinger Creme EggMichaszkiA Flock of Milk Chocolate Turkeys

I opened the wrapper to find that there were indeed just two pieces inside, but to call them pumpkin-shaped would be an extreme reach. They were just shaped like wide blobs, with almost no resemblance to pumpkins at all. It looked like they maybe tried to put a pumpkin stem in the bottom center, but it barely jutted out at all — and why the bottom?

As disappointing as the shape was, the good news was that these were still Reese's. The outside felt a bit melty on the fingertips, but each piece was fairly big, with a soft feel, lots of peanut butter and lots of chocolate.

Shop: Buy Reese’s on Amazon #ad

Smell test: The usual Reese's smell. Nice.

From the package: “Orange background color is a registered trademark.”

Online store: Buy Reese’s on Amazon #ad

Company: Hershey

Categories for this snack:

This snack was discovered by Jeremy at Target. Review published .

Most popular reviews

Banshee Bones
  1. Banshee Bones
  2. Takis Blue Heat
  3. Moon Lodge The Whole Shabang Potato Chips
  4. Granny Goose Tortillos
  5. Lay's Flavor Icons Wavy Carnitas Street Taco

Most popular in previous months

Latest reviews

Rice Krispies Treats SpongeBob Limited Edition

Still hungry? Check out the 100 latest reviews

What We're Eating

More ...

The Web Just Got Less Useful.