Reese's Outrageous!

Taste test: When I spotted this bar at my local pharmacy, I did a double-take just to make sure I wasn't misremembering the name of the Reese's Nutrageous bar. But it was indeed a new bar, and the idea seemed to be to take the elements of a Nutrageous — caramel, chocolate and peanuts — and replace the peanuts with Reese's Pieces.

Similar snacks

This follows a trend that Hershey's has been incorporating Reese's Pieces into many of their products, including Hershey bars, Mini Reese's cups with Pieces inside and regular-size Reese's cups with Pieces inside.

The bar had a lumpy exterior, but the bumps resulting from Reese's Pieces inside seemed to give it a more patterned, less random appearance than Nutrageous. I bit in to find that the core was made of a peanut butter/caramel mixture, wrapped in brown, yellow and orange mini-Reese's Pieces, then coated in milk chocolate. I could taste all of those things, but the Reese's Pieces dominated. A sweet bar overall, probably too sweet if I hadn't had it with some cold milk. Pretty good, but if you don't like Reese's Pieces, I wouldn't go there.

Shop: Buy Reese’s on Amazon #ad

Smell test: Pretty mild, nor really any strong peanut butter, caramel or chocolate smell.

From the package: “Stuffed with Pieces candy” ... “Milk chocolate, peanut butter & caramel” ... “200 calories per pack” ... “The orange color is a registered trademark.”

Online store: Buy Reese’s on Amazon #ad

Company: Hershey

Categories for this snack:

All Reese's Peanut Butter Cups (79 snacks)
Chocolate (1719 snacks)
Bars (911 snacks)
Peanut Butter Snacks (339 snacks)
Caramel Snacks (328 snacks)

This snack was discovered by Jeremy at CVS Health. Review published .

Most popular reviews

Moon Lodge The Whole Shabang Potato Chips

Latest reviews

Still hungry? Check out the 100 latest reviews

What We're Eating

More ...