Taste test: Do you like Reese's a lot? We sure do! We've reviewed 51 kinds of Reese's, and we're tempted by any new variety. This one stood out from the crowd not for its recipe, as it sought to duplicate the original, but for its sheer size.
It was huge! Each of the two cups was more than 10 times the volume of a regular Reese's cup, and the whole package totaled 2300 calories, vs. 210 for a regular twin pack of original Reese's. When we pulled the first cup out of the wrapper, it looked like one of those mini pies, except bigger and denser.
Each of the two cups was about four inches in diameter on top (narrower at the bottom) and about 1-1/4 inches thick. Just under an inch of that was the peanut butter. Since they looked like pies, I tried to cut them like pies — I got a huge knife and sliced away, and it cut cleanly and easily. I cut the cup into sixths (matching the official serving size), poured myself a glass of milk and held my first slice with a folk. It tasted mostly as expected, but it did seem a little different from a standard Reese's, probably because of the change of scale. The chocolate seemed less melty, and the sheer thickness of the peanut butter filling made it so that the two elements didn't mix quite as much as with a regular-sized cup. Given the availability of up to 12 slices of that size of what I ate, I doubt many Reese's fans could keep themselves to just one slice. Personally, I had three slices in my first sitting.
Good stuff, can't wait to see what Reese's dreams up next!
Shop: Buy Reese’s on Amazon #ad
Smell test: Not quite the same as original Reese's. Seemed milder.
From the package: “Total Calories per 8z Cup 1150” ... “Serving Size 1/12 package (38g) Servings Per Container about 12” ... “Amount Per Serving Calories 190 Calories from Fat 90” ... “Orange background is a registered trademark.” ... “the perfect gift!”
Online store: Buy Reese’s on Amazon #ad
Categories for this snack:
- All Reese's Peanut Butter Cups (81 snacks)
- Chocolate (1805 snacks)
- Peanut Butter Snacks (348 snacks)
- Snacks reviewed in 2014
Most popular reviews
- Takis Blue Heat
- Moon Lodge The Whole Shabang Potato Chips
- Doritos Late Night All Nighter Cheeseburger
- Andy Capp's Salsa Fries
- Tostitos Holiday Bite Size Tortilla Chips
- Pringles Scorchin' Cheddar
- Milka Caramel
- Hal's New York Kettle Chips Sea Salt & Vinegar
- 7 Select Flavored Jumbo Peanuts Wasabi Soy
- Jacob's Baked Crinklys Cheese & Onion
- Trolli Sour Crunchy Crawlers
- Yupi Gople Con Todo Original
What We're Eating
- Finally, Cheetos-branded mac & cheese!
- Lay's gets a new logo
- What does Chewbacca eat?
- Dirt Cake: What do kids think?
- The George Lucas Diet
- The long and crunchy road